How Can We Sing
Hymn text author Lindy Thompson reflects on the hymn "How Can We Sing" by Andrew Donaldson.
“How Can We Sing,” by Andrew Donaldson, speaks very well and very pointedly to the times through which we are living. Using strong imagery, the text asks how can we continue to sing when it appears that much of what we have held dear and considered inviolate is being cavalierly dismantled by “tyrants and kings.” How can we continue to sing when “our hope has broken like a bone?”
The words used to express this message are well-chosen and evocative. I was especially struck by the question, “Why does a lie sound wiser than a psalm?” Why, indeed? As we are led “from crisis into crisis,” there is no time to think, no time to consider, only time for sound bites and quick takes. We are pushed at breakneck speed – who can hear God’s still, small voice through such noise?
Ah, but in the fourth verse, that holy word yet. Things are as bad as have been described and “yet how can we stand silent?” Those who have come before us have continued to sing, despite their circumstances—we can be strong like they were and pray that God “breathe through our song.”
The text is paired with the tune TROUBADOR which complements well the questions and concepts being laid out for our consideration. “How Can We Sing” is a timely and appropriate selection for congregations to experience and ponder.
